Understanding Mental Capacity When Making a Will
Making a Will is one of the most important steps you can take to ensure your wishes are carried out after your death. However, for a Will to be valid, the person making it must have the necessary mental capacity at the time the Will is prepared and signed.
Questions about mental capacity often arise when an individual has dementia, Alzheimer’s disease or another condition that affects their ability to make decisions. In some cases, concerns about capacity can lead to disputes after a person’s death, with family members challenging the validity of a Will.
Understanding how mental capacity is assessed can help individuals and families plan ahead with confidence and reduce the risk of future disputes.
What is Mental Capacity?
Mental capacity is the ability to make a particular decision at the time that decision needs to be made.
Under the Mental Capacity Act 2005, every adult is presumed to have capacity unless it is established otherwise. Capacity is also decision-specific and time-specific. This means that a person may be able to make some decisions independently but require support with others, and their ability to make decisions can change over time.
When assessing whether someone has capacity, consideration is given to whether they can:
- Understand the information relevant to a decision;
- Retain that information long enough to make the decision;
- Use or weigh that information as part of the decision-making process; and
- Communicate their decision.
A person should not be considered incapable of making a decision simply because they make a choice that others may regard as unwise.
Can Someone with Dementia make a Will?
A diagnosis of dementia does not automatically mean that a person is unable to make a Will.
Many individuals living with dementia retain the ability to make decisions about their affairs, particularly during the early stages of the condition. What matters is whether the person has the required mental capacity at the time instructions for the Will are given and when the Will is signed.
Each person’s circumstances are different, and capacity must be assessed on a case-by-case basis.
What is Testamentary Capacity?
When making a Will, a person must have what is known as testamentary capacity.
The legal test for testamentary capacity comes from the case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870), which remains the leading authority in this area.
To have testamentary capacity, the person making the Will must:
- Understand that they are making a Will and the effect it will have;
- Understand, in broad terms, the nature and value of their estate;
- Be aware of the people who may have a claim on their estate or who might reasonably expect to benefit; and
- Not be affected by a mental disorder or delusion that influences how their estate is distributed.
This does not mean an individual must know the precise value of every asset they own. Rather, they should have a general understanding of their financial position and the consequences of the decisions they are making.
Why is Medical Evidence Sometimes Needed?
Where there may be concerns about capacity, solicitors often take additional steps to ensure that a client’s wishes are properly recorded and protected.
This may include obtaining a medical opinion from a GP or other medical professional with experience is the assessment of mental capacity, particularly where a client has been diagnosed with a condition that could affect their decision-making ability.
Medical evidence can help demonstrate that the individual understood the nature and effect of the Will at the relevant time. It can also provide valuable reassurance to family members and beneficiaries, helping to reduce the scope for future disputes.
Detailed attendance notes and records of conversations with a solicitor instructed to assist with the preparation of the Will can also play an important role if its validity of a Will is later questioned.
Can a Will be Challenged on the Grounds of Mental Capacity?
Yes. Concerns about mental capacity are one of the most common reasons why the validity of a Will may be challenged after someone has died.
If a dispute arises, the court Will consider the available evidence, which may include:
- Medical records;
- Expert assessments;
- Solicitors’ attendance notes;
- Witness evidence; and
- The circumstances surrounding the preparation and signing of the Will.
The court will then determine whether the person had the necessary testamentary capacity when the Will was made.
Challenges relating to capacity can be complex and often arise alongside other allegations, such as undue influence, fraud or a lack of knowledge and approval.
Planning Ahead
Planning ahead can help ensure that your wishes are clearly understood and reduce the likelihood of future disputes.
Seeking professional advice when preparing a Will is particularly important where there are concerns about age, illness or declining cognitive function. Taking appropriate steps at an early stage can provide greater certainty for both you and your loved ones.
A Will should also be reviewed regularly to ensure it continues to reflect your circumstances and wishes.
How We Can Help
Our Wills, Trusts and Probate team advises clients on all aspects of estate planning, including Wills, Lasting Powers of Attorney, Court of Protection matters and contentious probate disputes.
If you would like advice about making a Will or have concerns regarding mental capacity and testamentary capacity please contact us.
About the Author
Nigel is a Senior Associate in Machins’ Wills, Trusts and Probate team. A solicitor since 1984 and a member of the Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners (STEP) since 1996, he advises clients on Wills, trusts, estate administration and inheritance tax planning. Nigel also serves as a trustee of two Luton-based charities and is the legal clerk to the Board of Appeal to Table Tennis England.

Disclaimer: General Information Provided Only.
Please note that the contents of this article are intended solely for general information purposes and should not be considered as legal advice.